Failure to mention asbestos
When selling or leasing property it is absolutely vital to answer pre-contract inquiries accurately and the consequences of not doing so can be severe.
In the case of First Tower Trustees Limited & Anr v CDS (Superstores International) Limited (2017), a tenant of warehouse premises was awarded a seven-figure compensation after asbestos was discovered shortly after the lease was signed.
In reply to the tenant’s inquiries prior to execution of the lease, the landlords stated that they were unaware of any environmental problems relating to the premises. The landlords had in fact received an email from a specialist firm which reported a health and safety risk arising from the presence of asbestos.
Soon after the lease was signed, the tenant discovered the asbestos problem and very substantial remedial works were required before it could take up occupation.
The High Court acknowledged that landlords do not generally warrant the state or condition of premises before they are let and that it is for tenants to make their own inquiries, by survey or otherwise.
However, the statement that the landlords knew nothing of any environmental issues, when they had in their possession information that clearly pointed to a serious problem, amounted to a misrepresentation.
A term of the lease stated that the tenant acknowledged that the lease had not been entered into in reliance on any statement or representation made by the landlords.
However, the Court found that that provision was highly unreasonable and did not enable the landlords to escape liability. The tenant was awarded the costs of the remedial works and of arranging alternative warehouse accommodation during the period that it took to complete them.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Asbestos.
- Asbestos cement.
- Asbestos management.
- Asbestos register.
- Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 CAR12.
- Failure to notify tenant.
- Five signs you are at risk of asbestos poisoning at work.
- Material non-disclosure.
- Misrepresentation and insurance.
- Pre-construction information.
- Property disrepair and landlord liabilities.
- The risk of asbestos on brownfield sites.
Featured articles and news
HSE simplified advice for installers of stone worktops
After company fined for repeatedly failing to protect workers.
Co-located with 10th year of UK Construction Week.
How orchards can influence planning and development.
Time for knapping, no time for napping
Decorative split stone square patterns in facades.
A practical guide to the use of flint in design and architecture.
Designing for neurodiversity: driving change for the better
Accessible inclusive design translated into reality.
RIBA detailed response to Grenfell Inquiry Phase 2 report
Briefing notes following its initial 4 September response.
Approved Document B: Fire Safety from March
Current and future changes with historical documentation.
A New Year, a new look for BSRIA
As phase 1 of the BSRIA Living Laboratory is completed.
A must-attend event for the architecture industry.
Caroline Gumble to step down as CIOB CEO in 2025
After transformative tenure take on a leadership role within the engineering sector.
RIDDOR and the provisional statistics for 2023 / 2024
Work related deaths; over 50 percent from construction and 50 percent recorded as fall from height.
Solar PV company fined for health and safety failure
Work at height not properly planned and failure to take suitable steps to prevent a fall.
The term value when assessing the viability of developments
Consultation on the compulsory purchase process, compensation reforms and potential removal of hope value.
Trees are part of the history of how places have developed.